Ban Dispute (Acerius)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
166
Reaction score
161
Points
375
Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Acerius
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 5 Days

Your Steam Name: :D
Your Roleplay Name: Priti Nightfall
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:0:200951260

Why were you punished?: 2.5 - User, upon entering the Slums Warehouse so as to raid, shot and killed one of the occupants who was crafting at their workbench and not visibly armed. The user had not given any commands to the player, nor was there seemingly any prior interaction within the previous two hours to warrant such a killing.

Why should this appeal be considered?: New rule, it was a loud raid.

"When raiding a base, you can kill those inside who are:

Known to be armed
Not surrendering
Entering or exiting the property with visible weapons.

If you surprise someone who is unarmed during a silent raid, you must not kill them on sight."

I started the raid by shooting a person (which it was a loud raid)

Additional Information: Acerius banned me and did not even try to contanct in some sort of way to give my statement.
 


You entered the base via completely silent means whereby you ran through an open door meaning none of the other occupants apart from the one who ran away from you would have known you were raiding. You have then shot the individual running which is more than fair however, only at this point has this become a non-silent raid. At this point, you have given the individual crafting no time to surrender and the raid is a complete surprise to them so this situation would not fall under the exemptions listed under 2.5.

The text you quoted literally reinforces my point rather than yours. "If you surprise someone who is unarmed during a silent raid, you must not kill them on sight.". The raid would have been a complete surprise to them at the point you shot the first defender.

Reviewed with @Collier @sza @Creepis @MangoFracht423 @Viper @kerzify @Lucius Husky
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top