Action Request (Wheelchairman)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
84
Reaction score
48
Points
165
Your Steam Name: SemD
Your Roleplay Name: Harold Baker
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:40471512

Player's Steam Name: Wheelchairman
Player's Roleplay Name: Thomas Henderson
Player's SteamID: STEAM_0:0:521857385

Why should this player be punished?: Player went OOC and ignored gunpoint during a raid. Forcing us to wait inside his appartment until a staff member responded to his F6, instead of handling the F6 with staff after the fact.

** Note** Video provided has been cut up, since the original is over 22 minutes long with periods of waiting etc. in between. The entire situation is regarding a server restart that happened unnanounced, whil we already had possession of the player's planters. @kerzify already dealt with this situation regarding the raid itself, and no action was taken. I was unable to make a seperate F6 regarding the OOC'ing and ignoring gunpoint, due to me having to go to work. My fellow org member Besian Ali couldn't do it, cause he didnt have a clip of it.

Evidence Link: https://medal.tv/nl/games/garrys-mod/clips/mu5kbdiXvl2bZOjgR?invite=cr-MSw4ejYsNDgzNDUwNjc3
 
The admin got both sides of the clips and didn't do anything but tell them to hand them back.

So it was sorted they are just mad because it didn't go their way
 
The admin got both sides of the clips and didn't do anything but tell them to hand them back.

So it was sorted they are just mad because it didn't go their way
Admin didn’t ask any clips?

Regardless this doesn’t change anything in the topic of this Action request. As mentioned in the original post, Kerzify was not informed of this entire scenario, and didn’t rule on this, only on the planters. I was unable to make a seperate F6 at the time due to work.

The situation you’re talking about was handled already by Kerzify as mentioned above. Regarding the outcome is to be seen, since a staff complaint is still active on that.


The reason for this AR is you forcing us to stay in your appartement, by refusing to interact with us other than OOC. This took unreasonable time, where it could’ve just been handled via an F6 afterwards.

In terms of your comment regarding not going our way. This isn’t accurate, since we got a profit out of the raid, and didn’t lose anything. Other than our time.
 
Last edited:
I sent my clip the person besla was rude and didn't care if they broken rules
Besian playing the tough guy in RP is kinda his persona. He’s pretty chill usually apart from that.

Reason he got pissed off is mainly because you didn’t let him/us continue, and basically held the situation at a pause, waiting for your F6.


Regarding your comment regarding us agreeing to wait. I think our intentions were pretty clear. Besian made it clear numerous times he wanted to leave with the drugs, and told u u could make an F6, and deal with it via that way appropiately, but u decided not to.

This kinda forced the situation to a standstill, which resulted in us also making an F6 to just get this resolved.

I have a feeling u likely responded this way, because u were upset about being raided in the first place, taking the unnannouned server restart as your advantage. But that is outside of the scope of this report.
 
mate, I said, " Can we pause till we get it sorted and you said yes. No one knew the server was going to restart because 2 minutes before I died in a PD raid, so I can't really use the server restart as my advantage, as it affects me too
 
@Harold Baker Is it true that it was agreed by both parties (yourself & @Wheelchairman) that you would both wait until an staff member intervened?
When Thomas made it clear he wanted to wait we stopped trying, which is when we waited. But this was after all the stuff in the clip happened.

I am at work at the moment. Will review the demo of me and Besian when I’m home to get exactly what was said, if u prefer. @kerzify

But like I said before, I think from the clip it shows pretty well that Besian Ali (my teammate), was very against waiting. The only reason he did not shoot him at the time, is to not risk further escelating the situation after restart.
 
When Thomas made it clear he wanted to wait we stopped trying, which is when we waited. But this was after all the stuff in the clip happened.

I am at work at the moment. Will review the demo of me and Besian when I’m home to get exactly what was said, if u prefer. @kerzify

Please, that would be great.

I will contact you via discord and can review the situation.
 
Please, that would be great.

I will contact you via discord and can review the situation.
Checked back in my clips from the situation.

Thomas requested "Can we hold up until we get a response" only when we were already outside with the planters, approximately less than 10 seconds before Kerzify teleported to us outside. I responded "yeh yef fine", since u were there anyway already, my orgmate responded he didnt want to, but this was probably not hearable to Thomas due to the distance between them.

Below a clip of it. Please note that he asked this +/- 7.5 minutes after our first contact with him, and after all situations in the original AR clip.




As mentioned in discord. I am available tonight for demo/clip review via discord if u wish. @kerzify
 
Checked back in my clips from the situation.

Thomas requested "Can we hold up until we get a response" only when we were already outside with the planters, approximately less than 10 seconds before Kerzify teleported to us outside. I responded "yeh yef fine", since u were there anyway already, my orgmate responded he didnt want to, but this was probably not hearable to Thomas due to the distance between them.

Below a clip of it. Please note that he asked this +/- 7.5 minutes after our first contact with him, and after all situations in the original AR clip.




As mentioned in discord. I am available tonight for demo/clip review via discord if u wish. @kerzify
Below a short summary of my view on this situation, now we are +/- 2 days further since it occurred.

We were mid finishing the raid when the server restarted without any prior announcement. Because we already arranged for transporting of the planters, and secured it, we decided not to continue/start any new RP (as this wouldn’t be allowed per 6.1), and grab the planters to leave, as they had been secured prior restart, and would’ve been in our possession. Only thing that prevented this was the doors respawning locked due to the restart.

Homeowner Thomas later came back, and saw us inside. Due to 6.1 we wanted to avoid starting any new RP, and explained to him that: “we would leave if he opened the doors”, as we would’ve done if there wasn’t a server restart. We feel this was lenient and conforming to the rules, as if this would’ve happened without restart in place, he would’ve been gunpointed, mugged, and even possibly shot for refusing the gunpoint like he did.

Since Thomas didn’t feel it was right that he lost the 2 planters left in his apartment, he decided to speak OOC, and refuse any RP or reply to gunpoint, until staff intervened. Even though clear attempt was made by Besian and me in LOOC/voice to continue, and that he could deal with it after via F6, as normally happens when u suspect a rulebreak, or disagree on something. We decided to interact IC as minimum as possible with him, since we did not want to break 6.1, hence why he was not shot for breaking gunpoint 3 times, normally we would’ve shot a player for that.

Upon a few minutes later when we were walking our way out, Kerzify responded to the F6 ,and teleported to us, and settled the planters via LOOC. The only moment we agreed together (me and Thomas) to wait for staff decision, was +/- 10 seconds before Kerzify teleported. +/- 7+ minutes after our initial interaction, or anything in the clip mentioned in the original post.
 
Thank you for providing everything, I will keep in touch with you as we are within DM's.

I'll review the demo and all sufficient evidence provided by tonight and will provide an outcome.

For now, I believe I have gotten everything, so I will lock the thread temporarily to prevent clogging it up.
 




After reviewing all pieces of evidence, I have came to a conclusion;

Due to the raiding party consisting of two players, one of them claiming that they want the planters and to continue the raid, and the other saying it was okay to wait until a staff member intervenes, I do not feel comfortable with punishing @Wheelchairman for 3.4 due to getting 'mixed opinions' from the raiding party. Although, having an LOOC chat designed for situations like this, I do believe that LOOC could have been used to resolve this matter, rather than speaking OOC terms within IC.

In regards to 6.1 being violated, I still do not believe that a punishment for the raiding party should be issued, the server was restarted abruptly without prior announcement, meaning both the users were locked inside of the property they had raided, with no way of getting out, therefore as I previously deemed, it would be unnecessary to punish both players. The reasoning behind the planters being forced to return after this raid, has already been addressed. Although, I do believe that both users consisting of the raiding party should have left straight away, and not attempted to carry on the raid.

@Wheelchairman Please ensure that when you are in a roleplay situation, regardless of rules being broken, that you are staying in-character and following all commands given to you, clipping any sort of evidence and making a report afterwards, rather than trying to resolve it mid RP.

@Harold Baker & @søren Please ensure that you are following 6.1, regardless of a server restart that you both do not continue raiding a property, despite starting it before the restart, the rule still comes into play and is not void.

I will not take action on this report, due to the fact of both parties breaking rules, and I believe this to be the best outcome for everyone involved that nobody receives a punishment, but a firm reminder of the rules and expectations.

@Oddy
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top