Ban Dispute (Marine Putin)

[Frede]

Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Marine Putin
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 1 Day

Your Steam Name: Frede
Your Roleplay Name: Frede Russo
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:56480134

Why were you punished?: 3.30 - While an active raid was happening at Hungeries and assailants were nearby, the player continued to confiscate 3 weapons while other officers were dying during the confiscation.

Why should this appeal be considered?: I was told by another officer to confiscate the weapons so that is exactly what I did we cleared the perimeter beforehand and the officers that got killed got shot from the office window a block away so I returned fire with another officer that told me they were going to go raid office I asked if I should confiscate the weapons and I was told yes so I went right to confiscating the weapons. my question is is in the rule 3.30 it states if the guns are out in the open or have a risk of somebody taking them you are allowed to confiscate the weapons which there was a risk for confiscation of the weapons because one of them was out in the open and the other one was inside of a building with a person that was AFK that I was told by a higher up to not arrest. then after the moderator I asked him to pull my demo he then ignored my message I then asked him again and he ignored my message I then told him if he's not going to pull my demo or acknowledge my message please give me an admin as soon as I sent that he instantly told me you are being banned from the server. Mind you I only have one warning on the server I have not done anything bad and I do not cause any problems in the server I try to be a good model for the new players that are joining

 

[Mini]

Under review
In the meantime find yourself some evidence because as it does state, It is required for disputes. You have 24hrs to upload evidence.

 

[Frede]

all I have is this clip of me telling him to pull the demo and giving permission for some reason the demo on my end does not work whatsoever I have tried but it just will not work. But where is his proof for reasonable cause to ban me when I told him what happened and he would have seen it in my demo that I requested to be pulled? my question is what video clip did he see to not pull my demo and ban me for a day is it just going off of what he said she said? all of my proof is in my demo like I stated in the video clip.

Garry's Mod - Clipped with Medal.tv

Watch Garry's Mod and millions of other Garry's Mod videos captured using Medal.

medal.tv

 

[Mini]

Someone was killed 12 seconds before you confiscated the first weapon and then you were killed only 6 seconds after you confiscated the third weapon, on what planet is it clear for you confiscate weapons?

 

[Mini]

As stated, judging from the logs, it was obviously not clear to confiscate guns.

Reviewed with @Bnjemann @Scoot @HuskyD0G @Moonyx