Ban Dispute (Acerius)

Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Points
145
Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Acerius
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 6 Months

Your Steam Name: Giuseppe Scaletta
Your Roleplay Name: Saul Macdonald
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:116024695

Why were you punished?: 1.2, 1.4, 1.6, 3.4 - User was being wantonly racist and threatening their aggressors who had them zip-tied and under gunpoint, thus risking their life. In the report the user was not at all apologetic, nor exercised any form of self-responsibility, and instead claimed that they were a black, licensed legal professional in real life, which therefore gave them carte blanche permission to be overtly racist and that the server was infringing on their Freedom of Speech. The user also started making sweeping political remarks reted to the Moderator's country of origin for no apparent reason in the report, presumably as a means of insult or ridicule.

Why should this appeal be considered?: Hello,

I would like to formally dispute this ban as I believe the punishment reason does not accurately reflect either the events that led to the situation or the subsequent discussion with staff.

Prior to this incident, I had a roleplay interaction with the same player during which I attempted to mug him. Instead of complying, he pulled out a weapon and killed me. I submitted a report regarding this incident, staff reviewed the situation, agreed that the player had acted improperly, punished him, and reimbursed me for my losses.

Roughly twenty minutes later, while I was explaining basic gameplay mechanics (growing weed) to a friend who was completely new to the server, the same player returned, initiated another confrontation, held me at gunpoint, shot me and made insults regarding my country of origin. During this exchange, I used the N-word towards him.

I am not denying that I used the word. However, I strongly dispute the accusation that this constitutes "wantonly racist" behaviour. I am a Black man of Congolese and Nigerian origin. The term was not used out of racial hostility, racial prejudice, or because of the player's race. It was used during a heated verbal altercation and was never intended as a racist remark.

Most importantly, immediately after the incident, I personally contacted administration to ask whether using that word was against server rules. I voluntarily brought the matter to staff attention myself because I genuinely wanted clarification. Had my intention been to engage in racist behaviour, I would never have self-reported the situation in the first place.

I also disagree with the characterisation of my behaviour during the report. The punishment reason claims that I attempted to use my race and profession as justification for my actions. This is not accurate. I mentioned being Black because I was challenging the accusation of racism itself, which I considered to be factually incorrect. Likewise, I mentioned my legal background only after Acerius repeatedly referred to his own legal qualifications while explaining his position. I did not raise my professional credentials to place myself above the rules, but rather in response to a discussion that had already shifted towards questions of language, intent, and interpretation.

Furthermore, I believe the administrative discussion became unnecessarily confrontational and condescending. What began as a request for clarification quickly evolved into a debate in which my arguments were dismissed rather than considered. I felt that Acerius escalated the conversation by repeatedly appealing to his own credentials while disregarding the context I was attempting to provide.

Regarding the comments I made about the United Kingdom and its educational system, I do not deny making them. However, they were comments made in frustration during an argument about what I perceived to be an excessively censorious approach to language. They were not threats, nor were they intended to harass, intimidate, or discriminate against anyone. Those comments were neither insulting nor, to the best of my knowledge, in breach of any server rule. They were simply an expression of my personal opinion and my right to express it.

Finally, I respectfully dispute the allegation that I was actively threatening my captors or intentionally disregarding the value of my character's life. I would appreciate a thorough review of the evidence supporting that conclusion.

Unfortunately, I do not possess any recordings of the incident. Nevertheless, I respectfully request that the logs, report evidence, and full context of the staff conversation be reviewed again, as I believe the punishment reason significantly mischaracterises both my actions and my intentions.

Thank you very much for your time and consideration. Wishing you a good day!

Kind regards,

Saul Macdonald
 
Back
Top