Ban Dispute (kerzify)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
55
Reaction score
29
Points
235
Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @kerzify
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 2 Days

Your Steam Name: Spooky Pyro
Your Roleplay Name: Kate Collier
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:69780698

Why were you punished?: 3.4 - User failed to comply whilst under gunpoint

Why should this appeal be considered?: In the f6 I cited that I should not be banned because I was actively blasting music which is why I did not hear him. Truth be told I was unable to hear him and the only reason why I did not dispute it was because I was only looking at reporting person's clip which is in evidence
here is my POV ---> https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/lkPGp1Vbg6m7_lPvR?invite=cr-MSx5TlksNzExMDk4Mjg&v=7
He has his mic muted so you cant tell whether he is actively saying something or not and it appears like he was giving me and the other officer commands the entire time but that's not the case.
In my clip it shows that the only time he audibly said "hands up" was the same moment I clicked 1 on my keyboard and I pulled out my gun. If you slow my clip down to 0.25 you can see that the same moment "P" had left his mouth I already had began to unholster my mp5. When I first walked in I noticed him running down the hallway so I already began the IRL motions of clicking 1 and clicking the MP5.
To be fair at the pace and audio queues of his clip it seems like I did break 3.4 but it was very instantaneous and I feel like I reacted quick enough to already have my gun out in order to avoid being hostaged.

Additional Information: this is the song
 
Last edited:
In the f6 I cited that I should not be banned because I was actively blasting music which is why I did not hear him. Truth be told I was unable to hear him and the only reason why I did not dispute it was because I was only looking at reporting person's clip which is in evidence

2.7 Required Sounds​

Players must be able to hear in-game sounds, including other player’s microphones. Players do not have to use a microphone.

??
 
you didnt even shoot me server side as i didnt bleed. i had the other officer under gp and on my pov u are through the door go backwards then pull ur gun out and go round the corner.
 




I want to make it very clear that gunpoint begins when a gun is pointed at you, not when commands are given. You saw a weapon being pointed at you, and your first response was to try and draw your weapon. This is unacceptable. Had you run to your right, you may have had a reasonable chance at cover.

Trying to make the excuse that commands were not yet issued is pushing the point at which we expect users comply to a place where enforcing 3.4 would be almost unworkable, and very unfair. This mindset suggests you are trying to find any advantage you can in a given situation instead of letting things play out as they should.

Additionally, given your record, an extension has been issued. This is not as a result of the dispute.

Reviewed with: @Lhealey05, @Lucius Husky and @JJB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top