Server Suggestion "Rework" Pianos

[willydocker]

Suggestion Title: "Rework" Pianos
Suggestion Description: I appreciate that the current piano has a transpose feature, but it doesn't work the same way as other virtual keyboard pianos. Instead of simply transposing one semitone up/down, it changes the entire scale, making it a feature that's difficult to use if you play on a computer keyboard. I'm sorry the explanation sucks, but if you watch the video I'm embedding, it hopefully will make sense.

Another thing that would be amazing is if you could cut off sustain by pressing space (holding it would completely stop sustain, and it sounds like you're playing staccato)

Why should this be added?:
It would make people who use the pianos on the server very happy

What negatives could this have?:
No negatives apart from dev time, I don't believe the transpose thing would be hard to implement, considering we already have the option, and it only would require some tweaking

What problem would this suggestion solve?: Qwerty pianists not reaching their full potential!!!!!!!!!

Useful Images: https://medal.tv/games/requested/clips/kIaeXWNCyb4U5zQsC?invite=cr-MSxTaW0sMjIyNDI4NjM

 

[willydocker]

I assume the piano is made in Lua (I don't know much about programming, so correct me if I'm wrong here,) and this is craz,y but there are open-source piano systems on Roblox that have all these features implemented perfectly, if it helps I could find it so the devs can look at the code if it makes life easier

 

[willydocker]

I think implementing the "normal" transpose system for qwerty piano would also make playing the piano a lot easier to get into for new qwerty players, as with the semitone change system, you can transpose sheets to have almost no black keys, so you don't have to use your shift key every second whilst playing

 

[Lushi]

I dont understand why are people downvoting this without saying anything.

It is indeed a great suggestion and deserves developer attention, and all the players that like playing on pianos will definitely love to see this big change that makes it easier to use the piano.

 

[willydocker]

I dont understand why are people downvoting this without saying anything.

Probably just people who haven't used it and don't know how much of a hassle it is to play sheets on a keyboard in just 0 transpose hahaha
Thank you for the support tho!! I'd love to see this happen because I play a lot of qwerty piano, but unfortunately, I don't play a lot on perp as without the transposing it's hard to make pieces sound nice enough for people to want to listen