3.10 Punishments - Capital Punishment Reform

Messages
5,547
Reaction score
12,996
Points
1,165
Location
305
Is this a new law or a change to a current law: Change to a current law


What law do you wish to change/add:

3.10 Punishments​


Law enforcement officers have the power to punish government employees and members of the public, however they must follow the provided punishment below each law, punishments listed are maximum penalties. Permission must be gained by a Lieutenant or higher if an LEO wants to go above the provided maximum punishment. The use of Capital Punishment is not permitted.

Capital Punishment may only be authorized for convictions of Murder, and requires the explicit approval of a Captain or higher. Any execution must be conducted in a private location, out of view of the public, and performed in a humane manner that does not involve torture or prolonged suffering.

Why should this change/addition be made: Introduction of Capital Punishment provides for an additional sentencing option for severe cases where regular jail time may not be a meaningful outcome. While intended to be used only in exceptional circumstances, it allows the PD to respond proportionately to a crime / act(s) of extraordinary nature.

To prevent misuse, its application would be heavily restricted through mandatory approval from a CPT or higher, ensuring that each incident is thoroughly reviewed & considered on the merit of the incident(s) itself. With this, it'd be an exceptional measure rather than a routine punishment that you would commonly see everyday, which would feel a bit silly.

Introducing this option also creates more meaningful roleplay by allowing high-profile crimes to have greater consequences while introducing a new aspect of decision-making for sentencing, rather than just 10y10k and cya later.

Additional Information: Introducing this for other things that can be defined within the penal code such as "terrorism" would also be interesting to see, open to hearing ideas about that. Maybe have it so the person cannot be ticketed, which would make sense since they're being killed anyway? Discuss.

KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS KILL ALL ESPORTERS
 
Last edited:
This was half tested on the server yesterday, and it was fun. It was kind of a mess, but with the right policies, it could be really cool.

How would we make it work? Lethal injection is probably the best play. You should also have a longer respawn timer so you don't benefit from being killed.
 
This was half tested on the server yesterday, and it was fun. It was kind of a mess, but with the right policies, it could be really cool.

How would we make it work? Lethal injection is probably the best play. You should also have a longer respawn timer so you don't benefit from being killed.

I think it's good to have this implemented regularly as a foundation before focusing on things that need actual development, but have it controlled with policies like you said. This is definitely something I can work on within OS if it's deemed necessary to have some sort of guardrails.


Capital punishment would be a interesting counter to PD raids as well. I think it would be worthwhile as an addition if we can balance it right. 15 minutes but no fine would be possible a way it works as it would be for atleast 9.5 type charges.

I did bring this up in a recent call with PD SMT as well, however with it being so limited anyways it likely wouldn't have too big of an impact with how rare it'd be. But still, same thought.
 
as alot of people seem to be for this i will give some criticism.

a big plus for this server for me is that you dont get ridiclous jail time/fines for commiting crimes and it seems if you introduce this it will increase the time people are waiting. to be executed and then with the extended death screen.

not to mention the abuse that could happen with this

also why was this removed in the first place? i assume there was some good reason then
 
This was half tested on the server yesterday, and it was fun. It was kind of a mess, but with the right policies, it could be really cool.

How would we make it work? Lethal injection is probably the best play. You should also have a longer respawn timer so you don't benefit from being killed.

what's the need of lethal injection
why waste time? just line up a couple of pistol cops and you get it done in no time
 
what's the need of lethal injection
why waste time? just line up a couple of pistol cops and you get it done in no time
Just seems unprofessional lining someone up and shooting them down. Lethal injection or electric chair is prob the best way to go
 
What's the point of executing people if you can't make a show about it or do it in a funny way though? What meaningful benefits to roleplay or deterrence does this introduce, especially if it annuls any ticket and respawns you in 5 minutes?

I would agree with this suggestion if you allowed on-the-spot summary executions of murderers to avoid prisoner transport (only in emergency situations like when they're annoying)
 
Can we add lethal injection, electric chairs, and a shooting stage inside pd too maybe a area for public to see too
 

Similar threads

  • Locked
  • Suggestion Suggestion
Replies
41
Views
5K
  • Locked
  • Suggestion Suggestion
Replies
2
Views
960
User0
  • Locked
  • Suggestion Suggestion
Replies
19
Views
4K
Replies
16
Views
2K
Back
Top