Ban Dispute (Dekkrior)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
5
Reaction score
1
Points
165
Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Dekkrior
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 3 Months

Your Steam Name: Jack
Your Roleplay Name: Torgue Flexington
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:23921311

Why were you punished?: 1.6, 3.20 - Failure to upload a demo when requested, disconnecting with an open report. // Contact me if willing to provide the demo for a reduction in length

Why should this appeal be considered?: Hi,

I would like to dispute my 1.6 and 3.20 ban.

Dekkrior contacted me through an F6 report that had been opened against me after I shot a player who had participated in a raid that resulted in the deaths of my friends, Seff and Luke. Dekkrior asked how I knew that the player had been involved in the raid. He stated that he had reviewed the player's POV but still could not understand how I had identified them. In response, I suggested that he review my demo, as it would provide better context and explain my actions.

A demo was requested in-game, and I accepted the request. I received a notification confirming that the upload had been completed successfully. As the report continued for some time, I informed Dekkrior that I would need to log off soon because it was getting late and I had both work and an exam the following day.

Dekkrior then informed me that the demo upload had failed again and requested a second upload. I accepted the new request and once again received a notification confirming that the demo had been uploaded successfully.

After that, Dekkrior sent me a link to an external website and instructed me to upload the demo there instead. At the time, I was unaware that the website belonged to A1L and was caught off guard when I was required to log in using my Steam account. Because of this, I refused at the time to upload the demo through that website and was getting a bit frustrated as the entire F6 already took about 45 minutes.

I reiterated that I had to leave and requested an AR. Wished him good night and logged off.

tldr: I'm willing to upload my demo to this site, or somewhere else if needed.

Additional Information: I do apologize for not being as clear during the F6 as I could and should have been. It was late, and I was tired.
 


Please upload the demo to this link (this is A1Ls site again)
perpheads_demo_2026-10-11 21-55-03.dem

I can't assure you that you will immediately get unbanned, this is under review.
 




But,

You've provided the demo, and I've been able to see what I needed to. I don't want to be unreasonable; I know you said you had to go, and the reason this was issued was because you told me you were not going to upload the demo, and that it was not your problem in the report. If you had just said something like "I can't do it now, but I can in a day or two" this wouldn't have happened.

That being said, reviewing what happened in the demo, I can see that you did see the vehicle briefly, but you lost sight of it for so long and frankly didn't get enough of a look for me to say that what you did was fully justified. As this did end up being a valid kill, I won't be issuing a punishment for it obviously, but I will advise you to please be very cautious, and only take action when you are fully certain of who you are acting on. This could have just been another Red G-Wagon, and not the particular one that attacked your friends.

The ban will remain on your record, however I will be unbanning you effective immediately and you are free to rejoin whenever you would like.

Denial agreed on by @Medium @Bean Can and @jams to ensure this was fairly reviewed before I closed it out.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top