Ban Dispute (Tilin)

[Fracket]

Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Tilin
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 1 Week

Your Steam Name: Fracket
Your Roleplay Name: Tim Birley
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:1:564754478

Why were you punished?: 2.5 - User killed a player after mugging them because they spoke, when they told them to stay quiet. However, the player was speaking because they had been asked a question by another person in the user's party

Why should this appeal be considered?: This is a demo clip from Larry Roberts POV cos i didnt have my demo due to being banned. Anyways I was doing a raid with baba and larry and we mugged. I repeated multiple times to be quiet and he still talked. Then when he was commanded to to go the bathroom he said "Oooohhhh maaaaaaan" and i shot him cos of that. I missed my first shot which would of been an insta kill but i just killed him execution style once he stood up. In the ban reason it says i killed him because baba asked him a question and he answered to it. But he didnt do a question he did a command and then said that. He was never asked a question and then shot for it. HE was shot for making unnecessary sounds when told not to under multiple occasions.

 

[Fracket]

Also when i killed him like that. I was already 10 toes so me killing him didnt affect me in anyway

 

[exrobite]

It is unacceptable to kill players over minor actions, such as expressing despondency, regardless of whether or not you had previously warned him to be quiet. His speech was posing no risk to your life, and your friend has already confirmed there was nothing else in the building. You went out of your way to shoot him after taking all of his stuff, solely because you thought you could.

In future, just don't be a dick.

Reviewed with: @Creepis, @mocho, @sza, @Galle, @Headline, @Ellie