Ban Dispute (curack)

[Willy Paolucci]

Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @curack
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 2 Weeks

Your Steam Name: Real Mvp
Your Roleplay Name: Willy Paolucci
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:0:82635348

Why were you punished?: no follow gunpoint

Why should this appeal be considered?: I got banned for "not complying with gunpoint" and probably because my surrender animation was bugged for him (https://medal.tv/nl/games/garrys-mod/clips/kEthaapjaNpgBjxGa?invite=cr-MSxxOUEsNjczNzc1OTk) but from my POV (https://medal.tv/games/garrys-mod/clips/kEuaA4o3uIwZprcoy?invite=cr-MSwxQ1YsODg3MDg3Mg) i had surrendered and complied with his order to put my hands up. Then he ordered me to go inside my apartament,i didnt hear him clearly and was a bit confused even tryed to go inside cause i picked up the idea he wanted me in the apartament but he just didnt give me enough time to do so. I think this ban is unreasonable and also curak said that i lied to him about my headset dying,which is the reason why i didnt hear him clearly about the order to go inside my apartament,however i got the idea he wanted me inside you can clearly see me turn around and head in i even turned around to tell him im going in but he just didnt give me enough time and instantly killed me, no warning shot nothing instantly dead.

Additional Information: i legit told curack my headset wasnt working correct or bugged or something and he called me a liar, even thoe u can clearly see me trying to go inside and try to tell him im going inside but he just executes me way to quickly

 

[mocho]

Denied, you were given ample time to listen and comply (Mainly standing still while under gunpoint, you kept moving around during this interaction, moving forward etc), and even if it was true that your headset died, which I am not outright denying is true because this happens to me quite often, you should be notifying the user(s) in your roleplay sit in LOOC that you are currently unable to hear.

Unfortunately, you are expected to play at all times with audio and will not be considered as an excuse for this rulebreak, if you are unable to hear, you should be avoiding roleplay situations that are dependent on audio, or notify the other user(s) involved that you cannot hear.

Reviewed with: @Scoot @Tilin