Punishment Type: Ban
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Oddy
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 6 Months
Your Steam Name: Sorle
Your Roleplay Name: Charlie Sorle
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:0:51990442
Why were you punished?: 1.1 1.4
Why should this appeal be considered?: Check evidence for link - this indicates that messages outside of the community are not actionable. My community resolution not ONCE referred to changing my conduct outside of the community, it is a COMMUNITY RESOLUTION and as such my conduct changed WITHIN THE COMMUNITY for the most part - I received a communications ban for the one incident where I didn't.
I was then banned from the server for six months for communications which happened on a very private Discord server with what I thought to be only my friends, only for it to be leaked by a certain someone. It was not visible by the person it attacked - and on the basis of my action request, things outside of the community are NOT ACTIONABLE.
I was harassed TO MY FACE and I am now being told that this is somehow less actionable than private messages in a Discord server which is not inhabited by the person I was speaking about. On what world does this make sense? A very clear precedent was set here, I acted in line with this precedent.
Within the community, I was ignored and disregarded in the handling of a serious issue in an administrative forum, with a giant message just being ignored by @Scoot to focus on one point with a counter argument, instead of trying to actually deal with my complaints, to which I called them useless. I personally consider the ignorance and lack of care to be MUCH more disrespectful than this.
A critique of someone's performance of their role does not constitute and has never constituted disrespectful behaviour, as no attacks were made on their character.
As for "causing problems in help chat", I was taking the piss with someone I know. You've thrown that in out of context, I misused help chat twice. I did NOT cause any problems, go ask the guy I was clearly speaking to in my messages.
Has been some awful double standards in the handling of this situation, why would you set precedents about out-of-community stuff then immediately go back on them when it suits you?
Punishment Subtype: Server Ban
Appeal Type: Dispute[Evidence]
Which staff member issued the punishment?: @Oddy
How long were you banned/blacklisted for?: 6 Months
Your Steam Name: Sorle
Your Roleplay Name: Charlie Sorle
Your SteamID: STEAM_0:0:51990442
Why were you punished?: 1.1 1.4
Why should this appeal be considered?: Check evidence for link - this indicates that messages outside of the community are not actionable. My community resolution not ONCE referred to changing my conduct outside of the community, it is a COMMUNITY RESOLUTION and as such my conduct changed WITHIN THE COMMUNITY for the most part - I received a communications ban for the one incident where I didn't.
I was then banned from the server for six months for communications which happened on a very private Discord server with what I thought to be only my friends, only for it to be leaked by a certain someone. It was not visible by the person it attacked - and on the basis of my action request, things outside of the community are NOT ACTIONABLE.
I was harassed TO MY FACE and I am now being told that this is somehow less actionable than private messages in a Discord server which is not inhabited by the person I was speaking about. On what world does this make sense? A very clear precedent was set here, I acted in line with this precedent.
Within the community, I was ignored and disregarded in the handling of a serious issue in an administrative forum, with a giant message just being ignored by @Scoot to focus on one point with a counter argument, instead of trying to actually deal with my complaints, to which I called them useless. I personally consider the ignorance and lack of care to be MUCH more disrespectful than this.
A critique of someone's performance of their role does not constitute and has never constituted disrespectful behaviour, as no attacks were made on their character.
As for "causing problems in help chat", I was taking the piss with someone I know. You've thrown that in out of context, I misused help chat twice. I did NOT cause any problems, go ask the guy I was clearly speaking to in my messages.
Has been some awful double standards in the handling of this situation, why would you set precedents about out-of-community stuff then immediately go back on them when it suits you?
Last edited:
