From what I've seen in the demo so far: It looks like
@xhantium was close to
@obidan66 as well as Eddie at the side side of the building. He did spin around and run off. I'm not quite sure if that would be acceptable or not. But In my own opinion I think That Eddie had a chance to actually escape. Here is a video to show the distance you were both at. Showing him right beside the building's corner.
He then managed to get away successfully. Keep in mind since you shot at him now, he has all rights to run off and pull out his gun. He also managed to trick you by moving up to another property and waited until you ran past. No one broke any rules I don't think. From what I can say anyway. But the way he tried to escape
Should be noted. He did twirl and run around. making the time of escape faster. So maybe realistically he would of been shot.
Here is a video, Slowed it down on the time where he tries to escape. I think that was an acceptable distance for him to escape to the corner. giving that It was also night making visibility worse. Also you never had your flash light on. making visibility at night even worse. I think everything Eddie done was fine. So adding up: Rain,Dark and no light= great escape chance.
To find out information on gun-pointing
@Carrot has made an amazing post for this:
https://perpheads.com/threads/how-2-gunpoint.3349/