Forums | Replying to replies

[Lelios1]

Description of the idea: Have the ability to reply (comment) on replies on all forum sections, without being forced to quote them instead.

Why should this be added? (pros): There can be a small discussion on a certain point that was brought up by a player who just made a reply without having to fill the whole page with replies that do not necessarily talk directly about the main subject of the thread.

What negatives could this have? (cons): I can't think of any.

*Images: The suggestion might be a bit confusing, I mean being able to have this

on all threads.

Maybe I am missing something, I am not sure.

 

[Dank]

If I understand what correctly what you are trying to suggest is that a comment can have a subcomment which has a subsubcomment but shows up as a subcomment? And make it so it will show as a comment to the subcomment. This sounds confusing but if this is what you mean i would suggest reddits way of doing this by indenting on the subcomment. Like this:

 

[Lelios1]

If I understand what correctly what you are trying to suggest is that a comment can have a subcomment which has a subsubcomment but shows up as a subcomment? And make it so it will show as a comment to the subcomment. This sounds confusing but if this is what you mean i would suggest reddits way of doing this by indenting on the subcomment. Like this:View attachment 9600

And I thought my thread was difficult to understand.

Right now I am replying to you, which was a reply to the thread. I am suggesting that it should be a comment on the reply or a "subcomment" on your "comment", instead of being an actual reply but with a quote of your reply.

This is already a thing on the forums btw. For example the rules discussion section has it enabled. Try pressing "reply" on a reply.

 

[Dank]

And I thought my thread was difficult to understand.

Right now I am replying to you, which was a reply to the thread. I am suggesting that it should be a comment on the reply or a "subcomment" on your "comment", instead of being an actual reply but with a quote of your reply.

This is already a thing on the forums btw. For example the rules discussion section has it enabled. Try pressing "reply" on a rep

Ahh now i get it, sounds good yeah

 

[Sam]

I’ve not looked into this but comments are probably not supported in this type of node. This is a suggestion node, while the rule discussion node is a discussion node.

 

[blackdown]

I’ve not looked into this but comments are probably not supported in this type of node. This is a suggestion node, while the rule discussion node is a discussion node.

I believe that he is suggesting this for the rest of the forums, I understand suggestions are weird. I have also noticed a recent change in the comments function too

 

[Lelios1]

I believe that he is suggesting this for the rest of the forums, I understand suggestions are weird. I have also noticed a recent change in the comments function too

I'm suggesting this for every section that has them disabled atm.

 

[Sam]

I'm suggesting this for every section that has them disabled atm.

Provide a list of where they don’t work.
It’s not really something that has been done intentionally, probably outdated comment system.

 

[Lelios1]

Provide a list of where they don’t work.
It’s not really something that has been done intentionally, probably outdated comment system.

Yeah never said that it was intentional.
It's only on ideas and suggestions apparently (based on my great detective skills). If it's not possible to add it then it's nothing life threatening, just an annoyance.

 

[Sam]

It does not seem like the addon supports comments for "suggestion" type nodes

We will have to wait for the creator to add support.