I do agree that the argument is flawed, but the central point still stands, let's see how this pans out. Like ethan said, it isn't a change that will have permanent repercussions. If it's useless we can always change it back.
Suggested this for a while. As much as everyone wants to have everyone in their org. The purpose of this is long term people make more orgs. Even though all this would do is split Megalolis into 2 orgs making it pointless as the exact same thing will happen making no difference. This will make existing orgs choose their best and most active members. Meaning only active members are in orgs.