To me it looks like the sweater cops didn't know what they were doing (I say sweater cop because I don't know who they are), they probably saw a gun and was going to arrest you, or for whatever previous reason, but since you were running away and what I assume is them thinking you could pull the gun, they shot. Just some speculation.
IMO, A1L wasn't doing anything wrong considering he never shot you until you pulled a gun.
I'd say this is stuff that'll get picked out out in the long run, with less rule breaks like this.
The whole reason you don't like it is because it directly affects you because the PD hasn't had time to adjust to the sudden changes, people who were previously unable to sign up are now signed up. And some people, like Ayjay said are abusing the fact that policies aren't in place to make the test look bad. It's going to be a wave of new people who don't know what they're doing mixed with veterans who don't support the change which is what makes it look bad simply due to their malicious or ignorant behavior. People who are indifferent or supportive would follow the rules and guidelines to the best of their abilities. Current staff activity (apparently, from what I've seen and heard at least) also results in the server acting like the purge where most rule breaks go unchecked due to a lack of manpower and dedication.
I haven't seen anyone recognize people who follow rules well, but instead take special note of those who break them and only mark that with bold letters, then claim "it's all going to shit".
The only reason I think this might turn out to flop is because the PD whitelist and IA system is what's been keeping people in line, without IA and a lack of staff to moderate the PD's actions, it looks like a dog took a crap in the living room and no-one decided to pick it up to dispose of it and then talk to the guy whose dog left it behind. I've always considered IA the new staff team considering 50% of the player base is who this concerns. With staff who lack people to moderate, they've gotten out of shape, started messing around at times and getting burnt out from pure boredom and nothing to do, IA stole half the staff team's job.
With the PD whitelist removed and IA shut down temporarily, most of the server's recoiling from the sudden burst of rule infringements and saying "fuck go back" before staff has even had a chance to step up their game and adjust to the flow of reports. Most of this is honestly down to inactivity and lack of staff members.